After its premiere in the UK back in April, The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society received a warm reception throughout Europe, Australia and New Zealand. That’s due to its charming, old-fashioned portrayal of how a tiny English island suffered so much during World War II. The residents are given a new light when a stranger arrives.
Four months later, it finally graces the small screens in the U.S., where everyone can enjoy the heartwarming tale in the comfort of their own home after browsing endlessly on Netflix. Director Mike Newell (Four Weddings and a Funeral, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire) provides more than a typical history lesson.
Based on the best-selling novel of the same name, the movie is set in 1946. It has barely been a year since World War II ended. London is feeling optimistic about the future. For author Juliet Ashton (Lily James), smelling fresh paint on doors suggests a new start. She’s trying to get another big break after writing humorous columns about life during the war. One day, she receives a letter from a farmer named Dawsey Adams (Michiel Huisman, Game of Thrones), a resident of Guernsey, an English island on the Normandy coast.
While her publisher Sidney Stark (a deadpan Matthew Goode) suggests her to write about literature, Juliet sets sail to the tiny island after becoming so intrigued by learning about a secret book club developed when Guernsey was occupied by Nazi Germany as a way to avoid curfew (the movie opens up in 1941, where the members are caught by the Nazis, and must come up with an excuse). She receives a warm welcome by the group, and they tell their stories about the island and the disappearance of its founder Elizabeth McKenna (Jessica Brown Findlay, Downton Abbey), in which the residents refuse to speak about.
The German-occupation of Guernsey (and Jersey) has rarely been depicted in film. Newell and three screenwriters including Kevin Hood (Becoming Jane) do such a wonderful job providing a fictional yet authentic interpretation of the events that unfold, carefully bouncing back and forth between 1941 and 1946. With Zac Nicholson’s gorgeous cinematography, the Devon coast Guernsey is used as the backdrop for Guernsey, which he tries to avoid it looking like a travelogue.
Fresh from showing her inner Meryl Streep in Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again, Lily James is no stranger to period pieces. From Downton Abbey to Pride and Prejudice and Zombies to War and Peace to Darkest Hour, she has a long career ahead of her. Again, she proves she’s more than a pretty face. She delivers another delightful performance as Juliet, who understands how much the Guernsey residents have suffered over the years. Because of this, she’s also getting over a tragedy of her own. She leads a gifted cast of colorful characters including Tom Courtenay as postman Eben Ramsey; famous for his cooking his bland potato peel pie, Katherine Parkinson as gin-maker Isola Pribbey, and Penelope Wilton (another Downton Abbey alum) as Amelia Maugery, who gather around in a circle laughing, reading, and discussing primarily the books of Jane Austen and the Brontës. They reluctantly accept Juliet’s offer to write a book about them. “Our Friday-night book club became a refuge to us,” Dawsey says in a letter to Juliet. “A private freedom to feel the world growing darker all around you, but you only need a candle to see new worlds unfold. That is what we found in our society.”
While it might drag every now and then, The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (“Crikey, that’s quite a mouthful,” says Sidney) tells a fascinating story about something I knew very little of. Book fanatics and history buffs will most certainly get something out of it. This romance contains enough mystery to carry through. The best Netflix original film of the summer!